Political and topical news and commentary
One of the most expensive liquids on the planet!
Published on September 18, 2006 By adnauseam In Personal Computing
I'm sure Jusers have written before about the atrocious cost of printer cartridges. I noted a new HP advert the other day that 'pushed' their ink, comparing it to car buying. "HP. Very reliable.No previous owners." The ad goes on to say: " A new original HP inkjet cartridge is guaranteed to be exactly that: new.

Re-filled cartidges may have been around the block again and again, using the same print head. How many times? No one knows. More importantly, you don't. So, for reliable trouble free printing don't buy used. Always choose new."

They are quite right. I've bought refills that cannot put a smudge of ink on paper. I've also bought refills that leak like the Titanic. One refill I bought was not recognised by the printer. And, using syringes and bottled refill packs is a pain. Let's face it, if we want good ink we buy the originals!

Problem is they cost an arm and a leg. The other day I was despatched by my good wife to buy a new printer and some spare cartridges.I went out into the seething masses of Cairo to hunt down a "good " basic printer (no money for fancy laser stuff), and found one in Sudan Street for $25. The HP Deskjet I bought looked neat and good value. Then I bought two spare cartridges (one black, one colour), because I know the ink that you get with the printer is a "complimentary demo", i.e. has about a quarter of the ink in a normal cartridge.

Here's how it panned out:

* Cost of printer: $25
* Cost of black cartridge: $25
* Cost of colour cartridge: $30.

Ok, so I know the cartridges have a print head and are the product of sophisticated technology . I also know that they work well. But at what cost? I discovered, on looking at the packaging that each cartridge holds 5 ml of ink. That is sufficient for my wife to print out 20 photos or 30 colour worksheets. Ergo, one week. Furthermore, We all now know that the plastic machine that accepts these cartridges is worth zilch(ever tried to sell one?). Some conclusions:-

Result: 5ml of fluid ink prints 30 colour worksheets for $30. Black lasts a little longer. That 5ml of fluid in the colour tank is more costly than most fluids on Earth. It is probably more expensive than liquid Mercury!

We are being ripped off every time we buy a printer and ripped off further when buying cartridges. And Canon, Epson and Lexmark et al are just as much to blame.

We're in a corner here. Is there a way out?





Comments
on Sep 18, 2006
what did you used to spend on film and developing?   
on Sep 18, 2006
In the states, when you buy a new printer, it comes with regular cartridges (at least the ones I have bought), not the 'demo' ones. Of course I have seen some printers for around $50, but most of the decent ones are still going for around $100-125, so buying a new one when you run out of ink is still not an option. But at $70 for a replacement set (Lexmark), it is not too far off either!
on Sep 18, 2006

I just bought a used computer this April and had to replace the black ink cartridge this month,  for $20.00 at Wal-Mart.  I've decided against buying the cartridge for printing out photos,  it's cheaper for me to go to Wal-Mart on the bus, $6.00,  and make copies for 39 cents each,  less if they have a special going on.

Just my experience with this thing 

on Sep 18, 2006
PROTIP: High prices are not a scam.

They're a calculated estimate of how much you desire a thing. If the calculation is off, they won't make maximum profit from your business (either because you'll take your business somewhere else, or because they're not charging you as much as you'd be willing to pay).

The only scam is the one you're perpetrating on yourself, by choosing to believe that you must have printer cartriges, and that you're entitled to a lowe price for them.
on Sep 18, 2006
Last year I had a class that made us print out 20-100 page a week, often in color. I sometimes had to use 2-3 cartrige sets for one project. The thing is, the printer I got uses seperate cartriges for the different colors. Dark cyan, light cyan, dark magenta light magenta, yellow and black. Each one is about $18-23. It got expensive...fast.

High prices themselves aren't a scam. But when one full set of ink is as expensive as the printer itself, that's just ridiculous. Printer manufacturers under price the printers themselves, or at least get little profit from them. This makes them attractive to the consumer, who almost never takes into account the future expenses. It isn't illegal, but it is immoral. Printer cartriges themselves cost $5-10 to produce. Is it right to double, triple, or quadruple the cost? Not in my opinion.

Unfortunately I wasn't in the position to shop around when I was buying my printer since I needed it right away. But I would urge everyone to not only price the printer, but the cartriges as well.
on Sep 18, 2006
Wait till car makers get the same idea....and organise it with fuel companies.....$50 cars and petrol at $20 a litre ....
on Sep 19, 2006
Ever hear of CIS?
on Sep 19, 2006
I will never buy inkjet printers. Go laser!
on Sep 19, 2006
Wait till car makers get the same idea....and organise it with fuel companies.....$50 cars and petrol at $20 a litre ....


That just gave me a chill, Jafo.

Ever hear of CIS?


Center for Immigration Studies?
Center for Internet Security?
Citizenship and Immigration Services?
Commonwealth of Independent States?
Computer and Information Science?
Computational Intelligence Society?
Center for Internet and Society?
Cancer Information Service?
Canadian Interuniversity Sport?

...might have to be a bit more specific.
on Sep 20, 2006
Continuous Ink System?
on Sep 20, 2006
Randy gets a cookie


Link

Got mine on ebay for $65.00
640ml of Ink from Costco $18.00

I lub my CIS!